logo
Nachricht senden
Guangzhou Sande Electric Co.,Ltd.
E-Mail Sales01@sande-elec.com TELEFON: 86--18620505228
Heim
Heim
>
Fälle
>
Guangzhou Sande Electric Co.,Ltd. Neueste Unternehmensfallstudie über Yaskawa SGD7S vs SGD7W: Single-Axis vs Dual-Axis Servo Driver Selection
Veranstaltungen
Hinterlasse eine Nachricht

Yaskawa SGD7S vs SGD7W: Single-Axis vs Dual-Axis Servo Driver Selection

2026-05-05

Neueste Unternehmensfallstudie über Yaskawa SGD7S vs SGD7W: Single-Axis vs Dual-Axis Servo Driver Selection

Yaskawa SGD7S vs SGD7W: Single-Axis vs Dual-Axis Servo Driver Selection

When the dual-axis drive saves real money, when it doesn't, and how to tell the difference before you spec the panel.

Both drives sit inside the same Sigma-7 family, run the same SigmaWin+ software, and carry the same SIL3 safety rating. The split is simple on paper — one drive runs one motor, the other runs two — but anyone who has actually laid out a panel for a multi-axis machine knows the choice has a longer tail than that. 


1. What's Actually Different Between SGD7S and SGD7W?

In plain terms, how do these two drives differ?

The S in SGD7S means single-axis: one amplifier, one motor. The W stands for "double" — two motors driven from one housing. Both work with the same Sigma-7 motor families (SGM7J, SGM7A, SGM7P, SGM7G), and the commissioning workflow in SigmaWin+ is essentially the same for either drive.


The dual-axis design isn't just a marketing feature. Yaskawa's own product description for the SGD7W EtherCAT puts it directly: dual-axis capability "decreases system costs, cuts components counts and conserves panel space." That last point is the one most engineers feel first. Half the connectors on the front face. Less DIN rail. One bus connection feeding two axes instead of two separate runs.


Is the SGD7W just two SGD7S units glued into one box?

That's a useful intuition, but not quite right. Each axis on the SGD7W has its own power output stage, its own encoder feedback input, and its own dynamic brake circuit. From the controller's perspective, the two axes look fully independent — you can run one in position mode and the other in torque mode at the same time if the application calls for it.

What gets shared inside the housing: the network communication interface (one EtherCAT or MECHATROLINK-III port serves both axes), the main DC bus, the cooling fan, and the digital I/O block. That sharing is what produces the panel-space saving — and also what caps the per-axis power range lower than the SGD7S. A single housing can only dissipate so much heat before the design starts compromising reliability.

SGD7S — Single Axis

Axes per amplifier1
Motor power range50 W – 15 kW
Voltage class100 V / 200 V / 400 V
Network optionsEtherCAT, MECHATROLINK-III, Analog/Pulse, FSoE
Best forSingle-motor machines, high-power axes

SGD7W — Dual Axis

Axes per amplifier2 (independent)
Motor power range200 W – 1.5 kW per axis
Voltage class200 V / 400 V
Network optionsEtherCAT, MECHATROLINK-III
Best forMulti-axis machines with paired motors in similar power range

Specs drawn from Yaskawa's Sigma-7 SERVOPACK product pages and the official SGD7S/SGD7W selection manual.


2. Side-by-Side: Power Range, Network, Sizing

What power ratings are available, and how do model numbers map to actual motor sizes?

The model number convention is consistent across both drives. After the SGD7S- or SGD7W- prefix, the next three digits encode the rated current — and that current corresponds to a specific motor capacity. The pairings below come straight from Yaskawa's standard combination tables.


SGD7S Model Motor Capacity Voltage SGD7W Model Per-Axis Capacity
SGD7S-R70A 50 W 200 V single/3-phase SGD7W-1R6A 200 W
SGD7S-R90A 100 W 200 V single/3-phase SGD7W-2R8A 400 W
SGD7S-1R6A 200 W 200 V single/3-phase SGD7W-5R5A 750 W
SGD7S-2R8A 400 W 200 V single/3-phase SGD7W-7R6A 1.0 kW
SGD7S-5R5A 750 W 200 V single/3-phase SGD7W-2R6D 750 W (400 V class)
SGD7S-7R6A 1.0 kW 200 V 3-phase
SGD7S-120A 1.5 kW 200 V 3-phase (SGD7W tops out at 1.5 kW per axis)
SGD7S-180A 2.0 kW 200 V 3-phase
SGD7S-200A 3.0 kW 200 V 3-phase
SGD7S-330A 5.0 kW 200 V 3-phase
SGD7S-470A 6.0 kW 200 V 3-phase
SGD7S-550A 7.5 kW 200 V 3-phase
SGD7S-590A 11 kW 200 V 3-phase
SGD7S-780A 15 kW 200 V 3-phase


Model-to-capacity mapping per Yaskawa's Sigma-7 SERVOPACK product manual and standard motor combination charts. The 14th digit of the part number encodes hardware options like dynamic brake and encoder type — verify with SigmaSelect before ordering.

Power Range Coverage at a Glance
SGD7S
50 W → 15 kW (single axis)
15 kW
SGD7W (per axis)
200 W → 1.5 kW
1.5 kW


If any axis on your machine exceeds 1.5 kW, the SGD7W is off the table for that one — you'll need an SGD7S regardless of what the other axes look like.

Which networks does each drive support?


The SGD7S has the broader catalogue. Yaskawa offers it with MECHATROLINK-III, EtherCAT (including a variant with FSoE for safety over EtherCAT), Analog/Pulse for legacy controllers, and integrated Sigma-7Siec and MP2600iec versions for stand-alone motion control without a separate PLC. The SGD7W is offered in MECHATROLINK-III and EtherCAT only — the two networks that handle multi-axis synchronization properly.


That distinction matters more than it sounds. If you're standardizing on EtherCAT for a new line, both drives slot in cleanly. But if your existing system uses analog command signals from an older motion controller — for example, a CNC with ±10 V outputs — the SGD7S Analog variant is your only option in the Sigma-7 lineup.


3. What Both Drives Share (the Sigma-7 Features)

If I pick either one, what Sigma-7 capability do I get either way?

Quite a lot. The Sigma-7 platform was a step up from Sigma-V, and the core control technology is identical between SGD7S and SGD7W. The features in the table below are shared — picking one drive over the other doesn't change what the control loop can do per axis.


Feature What it means in practice
3.1 kHz speed loop bandwidth Industry-leading response. Settling time on positioning moves is noticeably shorter than Sigma-V or competing drives in the same class.
Tuningless mode Out-of-the-box stable control without manual gain adjustment. Works well for standard rigid loads. Saves real hours during commissioning.
Auto-tuning with inertia adaptation Maintains tuning accuracy across inertia changes up to 30:1. The same parameters work whether the axis is loaded or unloaded.
24-bit absolute encoder Over 16 million counts per revolution. Eliminates power-up homing and gives smooth low-speed performance.
Vibration suppression Active filters compensate for machine resonance, friction, and torque ripple. Especially valuable on belt-driven or geared loads.
IEC 61508 SIL3 safety Safe Torque Off and other safety functions certified to SIL3 / PLe — no external safety relays for STO.
Backward compatibility Sigma-7 motors work with Sigma-V drives and vice versa for migration. Most users replace the drive first, motors later.
Practical takeaway: The performance specs you actually care about — bandwidth, accuracy, settling time — are the same per axis between SGD7S and SGD7W. Pick based on axis count, power range, and panel layout, not on any expectation that one will outperform the other.

4. Does the SGD7W Actually Save Money?

If two SGD7S units cost roughly the same as one SGD7W, why would I pick the dual?


Unit price isn't the right comparison. What you're actually buying when you choose the SGD7W is panel real estate, wiring time, and commissioning simplicity. To break it down:

Panel width. Two SGD7S units side-by-side typically take 30–50 mm more horizontal space than one SGD7W. On a busy multi-axis panel, that adds up — sometimes enough to drop down to a smaller cabinet size.

Network nodes. Each SGD7S takes one EtherCAT or MECHATROLINK-III node. The SGD7W takes one node for two axes. On a 16-axis machine that's 8 fewer nodes to address, configure, and diagnose during a fault.


Power wiring. One main bus connection and one ground per SGD7W instead of two. Multiply by axis count and the saved conduit fill and termination labour become meaningful.

Heat dissipation. One fan, one heatsink. Thermal management of one SGD7W is more efficient than two equivalent SGD7S units running side-by-side.

List prices vary by region and configuration, but as a rough benchmark from US distributor pricing: an SGD7W-2R6D30B (dual-axis, 750 W per axis, 400 V class, MECHATROLINK-III) lists around US$2,849. Two equivalent SGD7S units at the same per-axis rating typically run 1.4× to 1.6× the SGD7W price — and that's before accounting for the extra cabling, panel space, and node licenses on the controller side.


Caveat: The economics only work when you actually need two axes in similar power range and similar duty cycle. If only one of the two paired axes runs at any meaningful load, the second channel of the SGD7W is wasted capacity you paid for.

5. Where Each Fits in Real Machines

Application Recommended Drive Reasoning
Single-axis indexing table SGD7S Only one motor; no benefit from dual-axis amp
X-Y gantry pick-and-place (similar payload) SGD7W Two axes, similar power, both run continuously — textbook fit
SCARA robot (4 axes, varied power) Mix SGD7W for the lighter wrist axes, SGD7S for the larger base/shoulder
Rotary table on a CNC (single high-power axis) SGD7S Likely above 1.5 kW; outside SGD7W range
PCB drilling head (X-Y stage) SGD7W Both axes in 200–750 W range; panel space critical
Multi-station packaging machine (8 axes) SGD7W × 4 Halves the amplifier count; reduces network address space
Press feeder (servo press + indexer) Mix Press axis often >3 kW (SGD7S); indexer in SGD7W range
Semiconductor wafer handling robot SGD7W Multiple low-to-medium power axes; clean room panel space at premium
Web tension control on a coater SGD7S Single tension axis, often higher power; analog command integration easier
Delta robot (3 parallel arms) SGD7W + SGD7S Two arms paired in SGD7W, third on SGD7S — or three SGD7S if power exceeds dual range

Are there cases where mixing SGD7S and SGD7W on the same machine causes problems?

Not really. They share the network interface, the commissioning software, and the parameter structure. From the controller's perspective, an SGD7W presents itself as two slave nodes with sequential addresses — so you can interleave SGD7S and SGD7W on the same EtherCAT or MECHATROLINK-III network without anything special.


What does need attention: documentation and spare parts. If you have ten machines in a plant and three of them use a mix while seven use only SGD7S, the spares inventory has to cover both, and your maintenance team has to know the wiring difference. Some end users prefer to standardize on one or the other for that reason — even when the dual-axis would technically save money on a given build.


6. How to Choose: A 5-Step Method

What's the actual decision sequence?

Five questions, in this order. Don't skip ahead — each step closes off options for the next.



Step 1 — How many servo axes does the machine have?
One → SGD7S, end of decision.
Two or more → continue to Step 2.


Step 2 — What's the highest motor power on any axis?
Above 1.5 kW → that axis must use SGD7S. The SGD7W's per-axis ceiling is 1.5 kW (200 V class) or 750 W (400 V class).
1.5 kW or below on every axis → SGD7W is in play; continue to Step 3.


Step 3 — Can axes be paired by similar power and similar duty?
Yes (e.g., X-Y gantry, two synchronized rolls) → SGD7W is well-suited.
No (one axis runs at 90% duty, the other at 5%) → still possible to use SGD7W, but the amplifier's full thermal capacity isn't being used. Cost savings shrink.


Step 4 — What network does the controller require?
EtherCAT or MECHATROLINK-III → both SGD7S and SGD7W are available.
Analog/Pulse, PROFINET, or another network → SGD7S only. The SGD7W isn't offered in those network options.

Step 5 — How tight are panel space and budget?
Tight panel, multiple paired axes → SGD7W pays back through reduced footprint and wiring.
Generous panel, low axis count → two SGD7S units offer the simplest spare-parts and troubleshooting story. The cost difference is usually small enough to ignore.

7. Common Model References

Model Number Type Description
SGD7S-R70A30A Single-axis 50 W, 200 V class, MECHATROLINK-III, 0.66 A continuous
SGD7S-1R6A20A Single-axis 200 W, 200 V class, EtherCAT, 24-bit absolute encoder support
SGD7S-2R8A20A Single-axis 400 W, 200 V class, EtherCAT, 2.8 A rated
SGD7S-7R6A00A Single-axis 1.0 kW, 200 V class, MECHATROLINK-III
SGD7S-180A00A Single-axis 2.0 kW, 200 V 3-phase, MECHATROLINK-III
SGD7S-330A00A Single-axis 5.0 kW, 200 V 3-phase
SGD7S-780A00A Single-axis 15 kW, 200 V 3-phase — top of the SGD7S range
SGD7W-1R6A20A Dual-axis 200 W per axis, 200 V class, EtherCAT
SGD7W-2R8A20A Dual-axis 400 W per axis, 200 V class, EtherCAT
SGD7W-5R5A20A Dual-axis 750 W per axis, 200 V class, EtherCAT
SGD7W-7R6A20A Dual-axis 1.0 kW per axis, 200 V class, EtherCAT
SGD7W-2R6D30B Dual-axis 750 W per axis, 400 V class, MECHATROLINK-III


Article numbers per Yaskawa Sigma-7 SERVOPACK catalogues and selection manuals. The 14th digit of the model code denotes hardware options (dynamic brake, encoder type) and varies independently — confirm against the SigmaSelect configurator before placing the order.


Bottom Line

The choice between SGD7S and SGD7W comes down to two things: the per-axis power requirement, and how many axes you have in the comparable power band. Anything above 1.5 kW per axis is automatically SGD7S territory. Below that, if axes pair up naturally by power and duty, the SGD7W is usually the better economic choice once you factor in panel space and wiring labour. If your axes are scattered across the machine with no natural pairing, sticking with SGD7S keeps the build simpler.


The motion performance — bandwidth, settling time, accuracy — is identical between the two. You're not trading off control quality. The trade is footprint and component count against the inventory simplicity of a single drive type.


If you're sizing a specific machine and want a sanity check, send us the axis list with motor power and the controller you're using. We supply genuine Yaskawa Sigma-7 SERVOPACKs (both SGD7S and SGD7W) along with the matching SGM7 servo motors, with full Yaskawa documentation and lead-time information.


KONTAKTIEREN SIE UNS JEDERZEIT

86--18620505228
10/F, Jia Yue Building, Chebei Road, Bezirk Tianhe, Guangzhou, China
Senden Sie Ihre Anfrage direkt an uns